Maintenance Records and Insurance Claims for UK Small Businesses
Published · gribit

Dated maintenance and safety-check records are the plainest evidence you can give an insurer that your premises were looked after, and they matter most when a claim is disputed. They will not guarantee a payout, because your policy wording decides that. But a business that can show who checked what, when, and what was done about any fault is in a far stronger position than one that has to reconstruct events from memory. For a small site, the practical answer is one organised logbook, kept as you go. We built Gribit for this: a digital logbook where you record check results, manage follow-ups and store certificates in one place.
TL;DR
- Your policy wording, schedule and endorsements set the maintenance duties you must meet. Read them first, because they differ from policy to policy.
- Under the Insurance Act 2015, a breached warranty suspends the insurer’s liability for the period of the breach. Putting the failure right can restore cover for later losses.
- Insurers favour records made at the time of the check. Records recreated after a loss may be viewed sceptically.
- Keep the check date, the item, who did it, the result, any fault and the fix, plus the engineer’s certificates.
- Name one person per task, set reminders, and keep everything in one place that staff can reach.
Table of Contents
- Why insurers ask for maintenance records
- What the Insurance Act 2015 means for you
- Find the duties hidden in your own policy
- Why timing matters: records made at the time
- What to record: the checks insurers and inspectors care about
- What a good record contains
- How long to keep records
- What to do when a check finds a fault, or you miss one
- Making it routine on a small site
- One logbook for every site check
- Our view
- FAQ
- Sources
Why insurers ask for maintenance records
When something goes wrong at your premises, a fire, a flood from a failed appliance, a break-in, the insurer’s first question is not only what was lost. It is also what condition the premises and equipment were in, and whether you did what the policy asked of you.
Maintenance records answer that question. They show a pattern of responsible upkeep: alarms tested, extinguishers checked, faults noticed and fixed. They also help in a quieter way. If an insurer suspects that a condition was not met, a dated trail is the quickest way to show otherwise.
There is no single law that says “keep maintenance records for your insurer”. The duty comes from two places: the terms of your policy, and the health and safety and fire safety rules that already require you to keep equipment working. The record is how you prove you met both.
What the Insurance Act 2015 means for you
The Insurance Act 2015 sets out how insurers can rely on conditions in business policies. Two points matter for a small business owner.
First, if your policy contains a warranty (a promise that something will be done, such as keeping an alarm serviced) and you breach it, the insurer has no liability for loss that happens while the warranty is breached and before it is put right. Losses before the breach, or after you remedy it, are not automatically wiped out. In plain terms, a lapse suspends cover for the period of the lapse. It does not necessarily end it for good, so putting a missed check right promptly, and being able to show when you did so, has real value.
Second, section 11 limits an insurer’s reliance on certain terms tied to a particular kind of loss, or to a particular time or place, where you can show that failing to comply could not have increased the risk of the loss that actually happened. Terms that define the risk as a whole fall outside that protection. To use the rule you have to show what the situation was, and that takes records of what you did and when.
This is general information, not legal advice. If you think a condition has been breached, or you are unsure what a clause means, speak to your insurance broker or insurer promptly, and to a solicitor if a claim is being disputed.

Find the duties hidden in your own policy
Before deciding what to record, find out what your insurer expects. Insurance guidance from a broker recommends reading the policy wording, the schedule, any endorsements and special terms for requirements such as alarms, locks, inspections, unoccupied premises, hot works and maintenance. Those requirements depend on the particular policy, so a neighbour’s cover is no guide to yours.
A quick way to do this on one sitting:
- Pull out the policy wording, the schedule and every endorsement.
- Highlight any phrase that asks you to maintain, inspect, test, service, lock, alarm or keep something in working order.
- Write each duty as a recurring task: what, how often, who.
- Note any duty that depends on an outside engineer, such as an alarm servicing contract.
- If a clause is unclear, ask your broker what evidence they would expect.
The same guidance advises giving each obligation a named person and a deadline, retaining dated logs, certificates, service records and photographs, and contacting the broker or insurer promptly if a requirement is missed or unclear. That is sensible advice for any site.
Trade policies often add their own conditions. If you work in a trade, this insurance guide for tradespeople is a useful starting point for how maintenance records relate to policy conditions.
Why timing matters: records made at the time
A record is only as persuasive as it is believable. Take empty premises as an example. Typical unoccupied-property conditions include internal and external inspections every seven days and a log of visits. A trade report from October 2026 on longer pub vacancies describes insurers preferring contemporaneous, timestamped inspection records, and treating records recreated after a claim with scepticism.
The lesson applies well beyond pubs. A log filled in on the day of the check reads as evidence. A log written up in a rush after a fire reads as a story. If you manage a pub, a shop that closes for a refit, or a village hall that sits empty between bookings, the habit that protects you is writing the entry when the check is done.
What to record: the checks insurers and inspectors care about
Start with what the law already asks you to keep working. For fire safety, fire and rescue service guidance gives examples of what to record: escape routes and exits, fire-warning systems, emergency lighting, fire doors, extinguishers, drills and training, repairs and false alarms. The same guidance says alarms, extinguishers, emergency lighting, signs, exits and fire doors must be kept effective, with regular checks and defects put right as quickly as possible.
A sensible small-site list looks like this:
| Area | Typical record | Where to go deeper |
|---|---|---|
| Fire alarm | Weekly test, call point used, result, engineer servicing certificate | Fire alarm test frequency |
| Extinguishers | Visual checks, annual service, replacements | Fire extinguisher inspection record |
| Fire doors | Check date, damage, closing action | Fire door check frequency |
| Emergency lighting and signs | Test result, faulty units, replacements | Fire signage requirements |
| Fire drills | Date, time to evacuate, issues found | Fire drill log |
| First aid | Kit contents checked, items replaced | First aid kit requirements |
| Portable electrical equipment | Inspection or test results, faults | PAT testing records |
Your risk assessment sits behind all of this. HSE guidance on portable electrical equipment says a written record of significant findings and existing controls is legally required when you employ five or more people. Below five it need not be written down, although recording it helps later review. Even for a tiny team, a written version is the simplest way to show an insurer what you identified and what you did. Our guide to fire risk assessment for small businesses covers it step by step.
What a good record contains
A useful entry answers six questions without anyone having to guess:
- What was checked, named precisely (“fire door, rear store”, not “doors”).
- When it was checked, with date and ideally time.
- Who did it, and for outside engineers, their company.
- Result: pass, fail, or a measured reading where there is one.
- Fault found, described in a sentence.
- Action taken, by whom and when it was closed.
HSE guidance for specialist equipment points the same way. Its electrical switchgear guidance describes maintenance records that typically include the work date and item, who did it, what was done, observations, test results and urgent findings. Fire service guidance adds competence details for the person doing the checks, and repairs or alterations to systems.
We go through wording in how to write a logbook entry for safety checks. The test of a good entry is simple: could a stranger, a year later, understand exactly what happened?
Keep the certificates with the log
A check log shows your routine. An engineer’s certificate shows professional servicing. Insurers and inspectors may want both. File servicing certificates for the fire alarm, emergency lighting, extinguishers, electrical installation and any other equipment your policy mentions, next to the log entries they relate to. If your premises have access control or alarm systems, it helps to know what access control maintenance involves so you know what a service visit should leave behind for your file.
How long to keep records
There is no single retention period for small business maintenance records. For portable electrical equipment, HSE says there is no legal requirement to keep maintenance logs, but a log is useful for checking whether your maintenance plan works. For some specialist equipment the rule is firmer: HSE guidance on local exhaust ventilation says examination and test records should be kept for at least five years.
The practical rule for insurance is to keep records at least as long as a claim could realistically be brought or disputed, and to keep your policy documents with them. If you are unsure, ask your broker which period they would want, and keep records longer rather than shorter. A digital record costs nothing to hold on to, while a lost paper log cannot be rebuilt.
What to do when a check finds a fault, or you miss one
Faults are not a problem for your insurance record. Unrecorded or unresolved faults are. Fire service guidance says defects should be put right as quickly as possible, and that further work may need a competent service engineer.
A workable routine:
- Record the fault the moment you find it: what, where, and how serious.
- Make the area safe if needed, for example taking a damaged item out of use.
- Book the repair and note who is responsible and by when.
- Record completion, with the engineer’s report or a photo of the fixed item.
- Close the entry so the log shows the fault found, the action taken and the date it was resolved.
If you miss a scheduled check or a service is overdue, do not backfill the log with invented entries. Carry out the check now, record the true date, and, if the missed item is an insurance requirement, tell your broker or insurer promptly. Under the Insurance Act’s approach, restoring compliance matters, and an honest record of when you did so supports that.
Making it routine on a small site
Most gaps in records are not negligence. They come from a busy week, a staff change, or a clipboard that went missing. Three habits close most of them:
- One owner per task. Name a person, with a deputy for holidays. Our guide to a compliance calendar shows how to lay out the year.
- Reminders that do not depend on memory. See how to automate safety check reminders.
- One home for documents. Risk assessments, certificates and logs scattered across emails and drawers are hard to produce under pressure. Our guides on safety document management and compliance evidence records set out what to keep and how to organise it.
If you want to compare approaches, paper versus digital logbooks covers the trade-offs for a small business.
One logbook for every site check
Gribit is a digital logbook for small businesses. You schedule recurring safety checks such as fire alarm tests and first-aid kit inspections, record each result, track follow-up actions, and store certificates and supporting documents alongside them. You can assign staff access, automate reminders, export records, and organise checks by site, item or location. That means the log, the fault, the fix and the engineer’s certificate sit together, and a new manager can take over without hunting for the paperwork.
A year’s subscription is £49 per site. You can see the plan on the Gribit site logbook page.

If you are still weighing it up, our explainer on the digital logbook shows how it works in practice.
Our view
Most small business owners we speak to think of safety records as something for the inspector. The insurer is the other reader, and often the more demanding one, because the question after a loss is simple: can you show it?
We designed Gribit around the idea that a record should be created while the job is done, not assembled afterwards. Recording the result, the follow-up and the certificate in one place is what turns a routine check into evidence you can find in a minute.
Paper logbooks and spreadsheets can work, but they rely on someone remembering, and on the document being where you think it is. Automating reminders and keeping staff handover simple takes that burden off the owner, so your time goes on fixing issues rather than chasing paperwork.
At £49 per site per year, we think a tidy, complete record is one of the cheapest forms of protection a small site can have.
Jon
FAQ
Will keeping maintenance records stop an insurer rejecting my claim?
No record can guarantee a payout, because the outcome depends on your policy wording and the facts of the loss. What records do is let you show that you met the duties in your policy, and, under the Insurance Act 2015, that a failure to comply could not have increased the risk of the loss that actually happened. If a claim is disputed, speak to your broker and, if needed, a solicitor.
Do I have to keep a log for every piece of equipment?
Not by law in every case. HSE says there is no legal requirement to keep a maintenance log for portable electrical equipment, though it is useful for reviewing your plan. For insurance, prioritise anything your policy names, and anything fire safety guidance says must be kept effective: alarms, emergency lighting, extinguishers, fire doors and exits.
Can I write up missed checks later?
Only with the true date. Insurers are reported to prefer records made at the time and to view records recreated after a claim sceptically. Do the check now, record today’s date, note why it was late, and tell your broker if the missed task was a policy requirement.
Does a small business with fewer than five staff need written records?
The legal requirement to write down significant risk assessment findings applies from five employees upwards, according to HSE. Below that it need not be written down, but a written record is the easiest way to show an insurer what you assessed and what controls you put in place.
Sources
- Insurance Act 2015, Part 3 (legislation.gov.uk)
- Insurance Act 2015 Explanatory Notes (legislation.gov.uk)
- Longer pub vacancies put inspection records at the centre of claims (Insurance Business)
- Warranties and conditions precedent (Portwood)
- Maintenance and Recording (County Durham and Darlington Fire and Rescue Service)
- Maintaining portable electrical equipment, HSG107 (HSE)
- Keeping electrical switchgear safe, HSG230 (HSE)
- Local exhaust ventilation (HSE)
- Access control maintenance in the UK
- Essential insurance for UK tradespeople